garbage mouth
BY JOHN P. SOUSA
I was helping my daughter Lily put her shoes on when she said, "Mom, did you just say Garbage Mouth?" My wife was sitting at her desk, across the room.
"What did Mom say?" I asked.
"Fuck," said Lily.
I turned to my wife. "Did you just say 'fuck?'" I asked her.
"Garbage Mouth, Dad," said Lily.
"No," said Ashley. "I said I was just logging onto the Angel Homepage to grade some papers for my online class."
"Before that," said Lily. "What word did you say before you said those words?"
"You might have," I said. "You know how frustrated you get with some of your students, because they're dumbasses." Whenever my wife, who is a community college history instructor, is grading her papers, she cusses like a sailor with Tourette's Syndrome.
"Garbage Mouth!" said Lily.
"I think I might have said 'crap.' Maybe," Ashley said. "But you know, Lily, what you can say if you don't want to say Garbage Mouth? You can just say the 'f-word.'"
"What?"
"Instead of that word, you can just say 'f-word,' because that word starts with 'f,'" I said.
"What word is that?" asked Lily.
"Fuck," I said. "Instead of saying 'fuck,' just say 'the f-word.' Do you understand?"
"Yes," said Lily.
"Okay, now go kiss your mother with that mouth of yours and let's get out of here."
I was not prepared for this. Garbage Mouth wasn't covered in any of the prenatal classes I attended, and it wasn't mentioned in the books I read. It also didn't occur to me until my daughter started talking, so I didn't know to ask anybody. How do you raise a competent, polite child when you still have the sense of humor of a fourth grader? Because when your toddler -- now a preschooler -- says or does something naughty, you're supposed to be an adult. But I have a near-Pavlovian need to laugh whenever my daughter calls the dog a "stinky butt club." Partly this is because my daughter is really cute, and because I love her, and so everything she does is amazing and wonderful. But deep down, I know that in my heart of hearts, I'm just a knucklehead who thinks poop jokes are hilarious, and loves to say cuss words, and so what I'm really doing is feeling at home in my natural demographic.
Thankfully my wife is slightly more adult about these things. When my daughter was 2, she loved to argue. And it was so adorable the way she would get mad and point her stubby little finger back at you and yell the opposite of what you'd just said. According to the experts, this is not good parenting, and so Ashley put the kibosh on me engaging in this behavior fairly quickly. But Lily's grandparents -- Ashley's parents, who are retired and spend a great deal of time with Lily -- are something else entirely.
For six months or so when Lily was 2, they had a running argument about my mother-in-law's watch. Lily would point to it and say, "Mama Adeline! Clock!"
Adeline would say, "No, honey. That's a wristwatch."
"Clock!"
"No, poopesh, that's a wristwatch."
"NO! CLOCK!"
My mother-in-law is in the beginning stages of Alzheimer's, so this could and did go on all day. As Lily got older and learned some astronomy, they had a similar, slightly more playful argument about the phases of the moon. "Half moon, Mama Adeline," Lily would say, knowing full well that outside the window was a full moon.
"That's a full moon," said Adeline.
"Half moon!"
And so on.
Ashley's dad, Papa Joe, would get into a much simpler and dumber argument with Lily. Out of nowhere he'd say, "Lily, you do it."
"No. You do it," Lily would say back.
Pointing this time, and jabbing his finger, he'd say, "No YOU do it." Lily would mimic this movement and inflection exactly a few times. (This is the adorable thing she did that I loved so much, and so I would start this argument with her occasionally, too). Eventually, though, Lily would get pissed and scream, "NO! YOU! DO! IT!"
All of this drove Ashley up the wall, and she was determined to stop it. Mainly she wanted it stopped because it's stupid and annoying for any normal person to have to sit there and listen to a grown adult
argue with a toddler. But more than that, despite our problems with blue language, Ashley and I want to raise our daughter to be polite and respectful, and to not argue with everything we ask her to do. It put us in an awkward position, because my mother-in-law's childcare was free, which was about what we could afford at the time. So we needed my mother-in-law to come over every morning and spend the day arguing with Lily about wristwatches and clocks and full moons and half moons. But we just needed her to do it without all the arguing.
And besides, Ashley has a theory about ending these types of arguments, which she calls the "Your Mama's Bush Theory." Early in our relationship, she explained to me that the ultimate argument-ender for arguments of this sort -- the back-and-forth/"Uh-huh!" "Nuh-uh!"/"Yes, you did!" "No, I didn't" sorts of arguments -- is for one of the arguers to say, "Your mama's bush!" The rationale is that there is no comeback to a non sequitur involving one's mother's pubic hair. It's one of the reasons I fell in love with my wife. And I think the main reason Ashley refused to engage our daughter in these arguments about clocks and moons and who is going to complete a task is that she was worried that she would say, "Your mama's bush," to her daughter, and all of existence would come to a sudden and furious halt.
As she got older, Lily became a prolific repeater of road rage language, 90% of which she got from Ashley. I can make this claim with confidence because for a year, they commuted together from San Francisco to Saratoga -- a one-hour drive each way, three days a week -- when Lily attended the preschool facility at the college where Ashley teaches. Not only that, but Ashley has a world-class vocabulary of curse words which can be mined at a moment's notice and deployed without warning on a driver who has cut her off, is tailgating, is going too slow, or has a bumper sticker expressing an opinion with which she disagrees. And don't ever, ever get her started on personalized license plates.
It got to the point where Ashley didn't even need to say anything. Once, the three of us were driving to the grocery store. There was heavy traffic on the street, and from the back we hear this little voice saying, "Come on, people. Fuckin' people."
"She didn't get that from me," I said.
Ashley, trying not to laugh, covered her face and said, "Is that what I sound like?"
"No, you're louder and meaner."
Just then, a guy cut into my lane and I had to slam on the breaks. "Aaaah!! What a douche bag!" I said.
Then from behind, like a parrot but much smarter, and with a much, much sweeter voice, we heard, "Doosh bag."
Then she said it again: "Doooosh bag."
And again, working the word around: "Doosshhh bag?"
And finally, because she hadn't tried it yet: "Dooosh BAG."
I couldn't really blame my daughter. She was, after all, 2 years old, and just discovering language. And "douche bag" is a marvelous combination of words to say. You have the hard "D" sound, followed by
that wonderful "ooosh" transitioning into the rough "bag" coming through like an axe to cut your victim down to size.
Then one morning, I caught her setting up her blocks and then knocking them down, saying, "Oh, Christ. Oh, Christ Jesus. Oh, my God. God dammit. Oh, God Jesus Damn."
This blasphemy was new and could have come from any of us: Me, Ashley, one of her grandparents. She could have gotten it from the TV for all I know. I have no idea what comes on after Teletubbies. But when she started getting on the phone with Ashley's mother and yelling, "Mama Adeline, FUCK!" we knew we had to start making some changes.
And that's when Lily starting learning about Garbage Mouth.
A partial list of words and phrases that are Garbage Mouth:
Shit
Fuck
Damn
Hell
Butthole
Asshole
Idiot
Stupid
Retarded
Pissed
Dickhead
Bitch
Son of a bitch
Goddamn
Goddamnit
Dick
This list is not comprehensive, and there are new words added every day. Some words, like "fat," for example, aren't officially on the list, but can be Garbage Mouth depending on the context. Context is
the hardest thing to teach.
Lily became the Garbage Mouth police sometime last year, when she was 3. It seems the only thing my daughter loves more than learning new curse words is enforcing rules with an iron fist. Any "damn" or
"shit" is met with a stern, "Garbage Mouth!" from Lily. We visited my aunt, who likes to read the letters from the editor in her local paper and sputter aloud about the "stupid fucking idiot" letter-writers. Lily, without even looking up, said, "Aunt Dian, that's Garbage Mouth."
"I know, sweetie," Dian said. "And there's a lot more where that's coming from."
This began the adults-get-privileges-kids-don’t phase, which Lily seems to have no problem with but makes me a little bit uncomfortable. In my family, my mother deployed a swift backhand slap to the back of the head whenever my brother or I let loose a curse word. Well into our 20s, if we happened to be in the kitchen with our mom and one of cussed, we did so while ducking.
Raising kids is complicated. You have to be on your best behavior in front of them because they're going to copy you. So when you're a knucklehead, like I am, you're constantly struggling to do the right thing. One time, Lily was in her bath, and she shouted, "Dad, I have to drop a deuce! I need you to light a match!"
She learned about "dropping deuces" probably from me, although there's also a good chance she picked it up from her Uncle Andy, who lived with us for a year. "Call me when you're done, and I'll come and light one," I said. The match in question was an incense match, a wonderful invention that clears the air of any foul odors emanating from the toilet after a bowel movement.
"OKAY! I'M DONE!" she yelled about 30 seconds later. I went into the bathroom and opened a new pack of French Vanilla scented matches.
"LIGHT IT!"
"Hang on," I said. "Did you wipe yet? Make sure you wipe." So, she grabbed some TP and wiped her front.
"No," I said, "you have to wipe the other side. You know, your..."
"My butthole?" It was here that I had to choke back a Pavlovian snort.
"Erm," I managed, still kind of snarfing. "Um, yes?"
"That's a Garbage Mouth," she said.
But here's the thing: my aunt had given Lily a book called The Gas We Pass: The Story of Farts, which has a pretty awesome diagram of the digestive system. Because of this, Lily is well aware that the proper word here is "anus."
But because I'm a jackass, I can't say "anus" with a straight face, except when I don't mean to. The other day, Lily and I were putting together a puzzle of the solar system. I reached for a piece and said, "I think this is Uranus." Here I was, having a tender moment with my daughter, playing together.
"It's called "YUR-uhnis, Dad," she said."Because your anus is gross"
John P. Sousa is a dad and a writer. He lives in New Haven, CT, with his family. He can be reached at: johnpsousa@gmail.com.































































Share Article